A New Big Three? Trump, Putin, and Jinping Meet
By Sam. N '29
On Thursday, November 19th, Donald Trump, Xi Jinping, and Vladimir Putin, the leaders of the United States of America, the People’s Republic of China, and the Russian Federation, respectively, met in Shenzhen, China, for a trilateral summit. Coinciding with the Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation (or APEC) summit, this meeting marks the first time that the leaders of the world’s three biggest nuclear powers have met as a group.

The main reason this historic event matters is arms control. The last nuclear treaty between the US and Russia, New START, expired in February, and for the first time in over 50 years there are no limits on the two largest nuclear arsenals the world has ever known. Trump has recently said that he wants a “new, improved and modernized” deal (AP) that includes China.
However, expansion of arms control is highly complex and difficult to achieve. The Pentagon estimates that China has over 600 warheads, while the US and Russia have more than 5,000 each. Because China perceived a lack of interest from the larger superpowers, Xi has shown little interest in an agreement. A senior US official called the meeting the “beginning of hopefully a conversation” (AP) and said no agreements are expected (unsurprisingly). So, the summit is mostly expected to be diplomatic posturing and less substantial negotiations.
Another important point is the symbolism of this meeting for Putin, as a disdained member of the international community. For him, cooperation with the leaders of the US and China gives him the platform to appear as a global superpower—part of the Big Three—in the midst of a stagnant war with Ukraine. Edgard Kagan, former US ambassador and now at the Center for Strategic and International Studies (CSIS), said that Putin wants to signal that he and Xi are “making decisions on Ukraine” (AP). Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy has signaled that he is worried that the meeting could become a place to discuss a Ukraine deal behind his country’s back, an approach Trump has taken in the past.
When a meeting is all symbolism and no negotiation, you have to wonder what the point is. A common argument against these types of summits is that they can result in rivals like Putin gaining prestige without others gaining much or anything in return. For example, the BBC reported that a recent US deal to import Russian diesel in response to the Strait of Hormuz’s closure has already raised European fears that Trump is softening towards Putin. However, supporters would say that with no treaty currently active, discourse is the only way to start rebuilding one, which is necessary to prevent potential arms racing. In fact, the White House even says that Trump believes nuclear proliferation is “very dangerous” (BBC).
Despite potential disadvantages to the scheduled meeting, it is likely that negotiations could lead to further progress towards arms control agreements, thereby neutralizing an unstable status quo.




Comments