top of page

Inside the Manchester City Scandal

1 hour ago
2 min read

By Henry S. '29


For a decade, Premier League club Manchester City dominated English football, winning 10 trophies and becoming one of the best teams in the world. However, in late September, an independent commission found them guilty of 114 serious financial rule breaches. This has raised a difficult question: how much of their success was fairly earned?


In 2018, hundreds of financial documents were leaked that told a suspicious story, chronicling over $900 million in sponsorship deals from between 2009 and 2018. While innocuous at first, the documents showed that instead of the money coming from the sponsors, the money had come directly from the team’s Emirati owner. This was problematic, as the league regulates how much money owners can put into their teams. By calling it legitimate revenue, these “sham contracts”—in the words of the Premier League—allowed the team to spend much more on players than they should have, giving them a considerable advantage.


There is plenty of corruption in football, but this case is extraordinary. It involves an entire decade of financial misconduct, and plenty of attempts by the club to obstruct the Premier League’s investigation. The Independent called it “unprecedented cheating,” and it is arguably one of the biggest scandals in the sport’s history.


Etihad Stadium in Manchester, England. (Photo Credits: Wix Images)
Etihad Stadium in Manchester, England. (Photo Credits: Wix Images)

The next step is a possible punishment. Manchester City won three Premier League titles during the period in question. Considering they had an unfairly good team, some have called for those titles to be stripped. Others have called for a sizable fine, making up for the extra money they were able to use. A typical football punishment is a points deduction, where some amount of points gained during the season are taken away, pushing them down in league standings. An even more drastic option would be to expel City from the Premier League. None of these punishments perfectly answers the question of how to punish a team that has cheated for years, affecting other teams’ outcomes and the integrity of the League as a whole.


So far, most City fans have stuck with the team, calling the investigation biased, with unfair targeting. The club maintains its innocence and has appealed the verdict, which many say is unlikely to change the result.


Whatever the final resolution may be, Manchester City’s case will leave a mark on English football. It has called their success into question and left fans unsure about the integrity and fairness of the competition.

Recent Posts

See All
Seniors of CPS: Phi E.

Interview conducted by Meera K. Meera: Hi Phi! How are you today? Phi: I'm good! Meera: I'm going to start with some rapid-fire questions, so you can answer these pretty quickly. Favorite Halloween

 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page