OPINION: You Can See Everything, and You Know Nothing (NO SPOILERS)
By Crimson P. '29
Seeing, to most people, is believing. The title of You Can See Everything attempts to win our trust before the documentary about Theranos’s former CEO, Elizabeth Holmes, even begins. But seeing something doesn’t necessarily make it true. What actually happened in A24’s You Can See Everything?

I, along with my fellow audience, left the theater feeling a medley of emotions, the most prominent being shock, confusion, and a strange sense of having been deceived. Yet, when we exchanged quick thoughts about the movie to one another, it only brought on more confusion. People who had watched the documentary three rows down from me had wildly different interpretations and theories.
This disconnect between people watching the same events was felt by the documentary’s team as well. In an article for Wired, co-director Nathan Fielder described his and his films crew’s experience within Elizabeth Holmes and her husband Billy Evans’ house: “At the end of the day, I would have in my head what I thought was a very clear idea of what was happening, and Lance [Oppenheimer] or our camera guy, Jonathan Mitchell, or our DP, David Bolen, or our sound guy, Richard Carlos, they would all have a very different take on what actually happened.”
All these people, having seen the same events unfold, left the situation with vastly contrasting interpretations of exactly what had taken place. This leads into one of the film’s central themes: how much can we really trust our own eyes and the interpretations they bring us, especially when discerning what is true and what is a lie?
Consider watching a magic show. At no point in the trick does the magician attempt to blind you. Yet, if the magician is skilled enough, you find yourself fooled regardless. Despite having watched the trick take place, the average person would still probably have no idea how exactly the magician pulled it off—even if they go to the magic show expecting deceit.
You Can See Everything, along with a plethora of the people it follows, could be described as deceitful in varying ways. Each of the main focuses of the documentary, Elizabeth Holmes and her husband Billy Evans, as well as the third party, Nathan Fielder, deceive both one another and us throughout the documentary. Between blatantly lying, deflecting questions, omitting information, and intentional ambiguity, these people leave the audience with far more questions than answers, even after delivering us what was promised: the ability to “see everything.”
The undercurrents of Holmes and Evans’ relationship, as well as Fielder’s changing feeling towards the both of them, further complicate the narrative. The documentary uses the assumption that the audience makes upon entering the theater—that seeing something equates to it being complete or truthful—against us. This is why I, along with others in my theater, felt like we’d been played in some way. We left with feelings of confusion and discomfort.
Yet, this is exactly what You Can See Everything attempts to convey. Shot untraditionally with an emphasis on intimate, close-up face shots, the focus stays on the underlying emotions of people, left up to interpretation by whoever is watching.
Although the audience can try to infer a person’s thoughts and feelings based on facial expressions, there’s no way to be sure someone isn’t acting or lying. At the end of the documentary, despite seeing everything, the innately mysterious and unreliable nature of people and their minds makes it impossible for us to truly know what, exactly, occurred.




Comments