top of page

Salt & Straw: New Competition for Ice Cream Stores on College Avenue

1 hour ago
2 min read

By Zoe Y. '30


On November 13th, 2026, College Ave gained another ice cream store: Salt and Straw.


Salt and Straw is a Portland-based, artisan ice cream shop known for its made-from-scratch flavors. Founded in 2011 by cousins Kim and Tyler Malek with a push cart, it has since expanded to 58 locations across multiple states. With this new Rockridge addition, they now have 10 locations in the greater Bay Area region.


In an interview with East Bay Nosh, Tyler Malek praised the community and strong identity of the Rockridge neighborhood, saying, “opening up in these communities where you can pull in the local PTA, you can pull in the local chefs from that neighborhood…there’s something about this passion for community that I think results in just a really passionate scoop shop for us.”


Salt and Straw is known for its creative and location-exclusive flavors. For this new “scoop shop,” Malek partnered with Fra'Mani, a Berkeley artisanal charcuterie shop, to craft exclusive savory flavors like Calabrese Salami (paired with honey butter-frosted dinner rolls), and a mortadella and pistachio ice cream sandwich.


Additionally, they have a monthly rotation of flavors. Their November menu is based on a classic Thanksgiving dinner, with options like “Pumpkin Pie with Almond Croissant Streusel.” For those who prefer more traditional flavors, their permanent menu includes “Double Fold Vanilla,” “Chocolate Gooey Brownie,” and a vegan "Freckled Mint Chocolate Chip.”


Photo Credits: Wix Images
Photo Credits: Wix Images

The opening of Salt and Straw adds another layer of complexity to an already tense ice cream scene. There are now five ice cream shops (Salt and Straw, Humphry Slocombe, Tara’s Organic Ice Cream, Miharu Ice Cream, and Bad Walters) within a couple blocks on College Ave, in addition to two other restaurants that serve Straus Soft Serve (Bakers & Commons and the Station), and Italian Homemade, which serves gelato. In fact, College Ave boasts one of the highest concentrations of ice cream shops within the greater Berkeley/Oakland area.


There is no clear consensus as to which ice cream shop is best. Many offer unique and unexpected flavors with seasonal additions, and have consistently high pricing, charging approximately $6-$7 dollars for a single scoop. Furthermore, they all have above a four star rating on Google, with Miharu leading at a five-star rating with 73 reviews. With such a level playing field, everyone has different opinions on which store is the best.


Highlighted Flavors:

Salt and Straw: Turkey and Bacon Caramel*, Strawberry Honey Balsamic with Black Pepper

Humphry Slocombe: Secret Breakfast, Elaichi Banana Chai

Tara’s Organic Ice Cream: Saffron, Epazote (Mexican tea)*, Lemongrass Sorbet

Miharu Ice Cream: Shrikhand (indian dessert)*, Lychee w/ Raspberry Rose Swirl

Bad Walters: Pumpkin Pecan Pie,* Crunch Berry Supreme

*limited or seasonal flavor


So next time you walk down to College, try to explore all these ice cream shops to form an opinion on which one you think is best.

Recent Posts

See All
Seniors of CPS: Phi E.

Interview conducted by Meera K. Meera: Hi Phi! How are you today? Phi: I'm good! Meera: I'm going to start with some rapid-fire questions, so you can answer these pretty quickly. Favorite Halloween

 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page